Historic house corner with clapboard siding meeting a brick chimney above a fieldstone wall.

Mill Hill Road’s Listings and the Businesses Around Them

Drive the quarter mile of Mill Hill Road between the Village Green and the old Bearsville turnoff this September and you will pass three properties with a broker's name attached to them. The Overlook News reports that the Woodstock Pub, at 17 Mill Hill Road, has an asking price of $1.8 million. A few doors up, the buildings that housed Gemela through last winter are now open again as The Penny Tavern and The Penny Cafe, sitting on a parcel the Ballinger family has listed for sale even as the new tenants unpack their menus. Out past the village center, the fifteen-acre Bearsville Center, home to the Bearsville Theater and Utopia Studios, carries a $7.995 million price tag. If you only read the signs, you'd guess Woodstock's commercial spine is coming apart at the seams.

It isn't. What's actually happening on Mill Hill Road is that several properties are on the market while businesses continue operating at some sites and new ones have opened at another. The distinction matters if you live here: some listed properties still have operating tenants, while Gemela closed before the Penny Tavern and Cafe opened.

The Corner That Keeps Changing Its Name, Not Its Purpose

The stretch at 43-45 Mill Hill Road has cycled through concepts for years: the Mud Club and Early Terrible operated there before restaurateur Craig Leonard and a partner opened the café Gemela on the site. Gemela closed for the winter and didn't reopen. In its place, Leonard and his three partners in the restaurant Silvia, his wife Betty Choi, her sister Doris Choi, and Doris's husband Niall Grant, opened two new concepts on May 1: The Penny Tavern in the larger building, serving lunch and expanding into dinner and bar service, and The Penny Cafe next door, built around coffee, egg sandwiches, and grab-and-go food. A commercial listing for the property, updated as recently as May, now describes it as an income-producing investment with the Penny Cafe and Tavern already installed as the operating tenant.

The same ownership group also secured Planning Board approval this past January for a two-and-a-half-story, 17-room hotel on the adjacent lot at 39 Mill Hill Road, the former site of Woodstock Automotive. Neighbors raised concerns at the hearing, traffic on nearby Mowers Lane and building height among them, and the board approved the project with screening and tree plantings written into the conditions. The owners said at the time they hoped to break ground that spring.

So the property is for sale, while The Penny Tavern and The Penny Cafe are open. The Ballinger family owns the real estate, not the restaurant, and has put the site on the market. The Choi and Leonard group, who already run Silvia and the Southeast Asian restaurant Good Night on Rock City Road, are the ones planning a hotel next door.

The Woodstock Pub Is on the Market

A short walk up the road, at 17 Mill Hill Road, the Woodstock Pub tells a different kind of story. The Overlook News recounts the building's history alongside its current listing. The address has worn several names over the decades. Woodstock's assistant town historian, Janine L. Mower, has described the building's earlier life as The Irvington, a nightlife stop in the 1940s and '50s when a night out in the village meant hopping between it, Deanies, and the Brass Rail. It later became the Woodstock Pub, then the Landau Grill, then the Woodstock Pub again under new owners.

Chris Constant of West Hurley, his sister Jennifer Ahearn of Woodstock, and their brother James Constant of Saugerties are the current owners. The siblings bought the pub in 2018 for $900,000 and are now asking $1.8 million, exactly double. Chris Constant put it simply when the listing went up: he loves the place, but times are changing.

Nothing about that listing means the pub is struggling. The building's listing highlights a legal occupancy of 151, a full commercial kitchen, and a rooftop bar already engineered into the structure, the kind of specs a broker uses to sell a healthy operation, not a distressed one. The pub is still open under its current hours as of this writing. What's for sale is the next thirty years of ownership, not the next thirty days of service.

Why Lizzie Vann Is Selling the Thing She Just Finished Fixing

The biggest number on the road belongs to Bearsville Center, the fifteen-acre complex a mile or so out Route 212 that includes the Bearsville Theater, Utopia Studios, the Bear Cantina, Tinker Street Tavern, and Pho Tibet. British entrepreneur Lizzie Vann bought the property in September 2019 for $2.5 million, when the roofs were rotting, Sawkill Creek ran through the basement of the old Bear Café, and the Utopia building was structurally leaning. She has said she spent roughly $6.5 million rebuilding it: new roofs, new electrical and HVAC, mold remediation, drainage work, and a sound system later upgraded by concert promoter Peter Shapiro's DayGlo Presents, which took over the theater's booking in 2024.

Vann listed the complex this past January for $7,995,000 through SVN/Deegan-Collins Commercial Realty. NYS Music reported:

"My job here is done. The Bearsville Center is in perfect shape, thriving with concerts, housing, dining, and a world-class recording studio. We can now turn our undivided attention to Woodstock's former library and funeral home site, with a vision of creating an in-town park, adding affordable housing, and so much more."

That next project has a name: Project Regeneration. Vann already owns the former Lasher Funeral Home site and the former Woodstock Library building on Tinker Street, the library having relocated to a newer facility on Dixon Avenue and the funeral home having closed in 2022. Her plan converts six buildings across those parcels into green, low-cost rental housing, co-working space, rooms for medical and wellness practitioners, and an expanded public park. The proceeds from the Bearsville sale are earmarked to fund it directly, one project's exit financing the next project's build-out.

Pete Caigan, who runs Utopia Studios inside Bearsville Center and has hosted recording sessions for The Lumineers, felt the need to post publicly after fielding fifteen inquiries in twenty-four hours about whether his lease would survive a sale. It will. Vann has said every tenant, including Utopia, the Bear Cantina, Tinker Street Tavern, and Pho Tibet, holds a long-term lease that transfers with the property, making the sale effectively turnkey for whoever buys it.

What Actually Changes If You Live Here

Put the three property listings side by side and the pattern is legible: Bearsville Center, the property occupied by the Penny Tavern and Cafe, and the Woodstock Pub are on the market. Alongside those listings is a business change at the former Gemela site: the Penny Tavern and Cafe opened there after Gemela closed, with an approved 17-room hotel slated for the lot next door.

If you're a regular at the Bear Cantina or Tinker Street Tavern, your lease-protected favorite isn't moving. If you've been meaning to try the Penny Cafe's egg sandwiches, they're already being served, whoever eventually buys the building underneath them. If you've watched the Woodstock Pub's rooftop-bar potential get talked about for years, a change in ownership might finally be the thing that builds it. The risk on this stretch of road isn't vacancy. It's turnover in the specific sense of new operators inheriting long-established footprints, for better or worse depending on who buys.

The Next Half Mile

Watch two things through the fall. The 39 Mill Hill Road hotel, approved this past January, is the first net-new commercial construction on this stretch in years, and its opening will be the clearest signal of how much additional foot traffic the corridor can actually absorb. And Project Regeneration's site, once the zoning question the Town Board has been asked to resolve gets settled, will convert two long-vacant Tinker Street buildings into the kind of below-market housing and shared workspace Woodstock has debated needing for a long time. Neither project depends on who ends up owning the Bearsville marquee or the Woodstock Pub's kitchen. Both depend on approvals that are already most of the way through the pipeline.

The for-sale signs on Mill Hill Road aren't a symptom of a village losing its footing. They reflect several properties being offered for sale at once, even as some businesses continue operating and others have recently opened after a closure.

If you're watching this corner of Woodstock and wondering what a building like these might actually be worth, or what its next chapter could look like under different ownership, Annabel Taylor would love to talk it through. Let's tell your home's story.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Work With Us

Together, they a bring best in class expertise of the luxury marketplace, a deep appreciation for architectural integrity and history, and an emphasis on design and technology.

Follow Us on Instagram